The Best Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktails

Raise your hand if a spoonful of peanut butter is one of your go-to midnight snacks? Alright, now raise your hand if whiskey is your go-to drink? Great. What if we told you peanut butter whiskey is a real thing? Would you freak out? We did.

To think a rich, smooth, and timeless spread could complement such a bold, powerful drink makes our heads spin. But, they work. They work reallllyyy well together. In fact, we made you a list of some of our favorite pairings.

Peanut Butter Cup Whiskey Martini

This smooth and creamy cocktail will make you rethink every overpriced dessert cocktail you’ve ever had. Think you’ve seen every martini possible? Think again.

To make this decadent, chocolatey, peanut butter, dream in a glass, begin with chopping up some peanut butter cups. Then, line the rim of the glass with peanut butter, and dip into the chopped peanut butter cups. Take your lovely little shaker and add in some ice cubes, Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey, chocolate liqueur, creme de cocoa, heavy cream, and a dash of chocolate syrup if you’re feeling fancy (you are so fancy). Shake that baby up, and you’ve got yourself a little glass of heaven.

2 ounces Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey
2 ounces chocolate liqueur
2 ounces crème de cocoa
1/2 ounce heavy cream
A squirt of chocolate syrup

Skrewball Hot Chocolate

Buur…it’s so cold, if only we had something creamy and delicious to warm us up. Oh, wait – what were we thinking? We could easily make a Skrewball hot chocolate. Just make a regular hot chocolate, stir in a shot of Skrewball Whiskey, and top it with whipped cream. You’ll be warm in no time.

1 ½ oz Skrewball
6 oz hot chocolate
Whipped Cream

Skrewed Up Coffee

Not being able to drink alcohol with your coffee should be illegal. If your morning consists of a mild hangover, it may be a good idea to take on the “hair of the dog.” With your coffee already brewed, add Skrewball Whiskey, Kahlua, and creamer of choice. It’ll wake you up, that’s for sure.

1.5 oz Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey
1.5 oz Kahlua
6 oz Coffee
Cream or milk

Peanut Butter White Russian

They said, “White russian but make it 1000 times better.” And we said, “Yes.” With this creamy and boozy cocktail, you’re going to legitimately impress yourself with how good this turns out. Get some ice in your mixing glass, pour vodka, coffee liqueur, cream of coconut, and heavy cream into it. Then to top it all off, add a shot of Skrewball whiskey. Shake it up, pour it into the fanciest glass you own, and if you want to take it to another level, add a dash of cinnamon on top.

1.5 oz. Skrewball Whiskey
.5 oz. Vodka
.5 oz. Coffee liqueur
1 oz. Cream of coconut
1 oz. Heavy cream
Sprinkle of cinnamon

Adult Peanut Butter & Jelly

It’s always nostalgic when you put a twist on an ultimate classic. Yes, we’re talking edges cut, lunch box style, PB&J sandwiches. Now that we’re all adults here, we’re allowed to have a little fun with our ode to childhood. Combine raspberry liqueur, half and half, and skrewball whiskey into a shaker with ice. Strain it into your glass, and garnish with a couple of peanuts. Then, close your eyes – let it take you.