Bulleit vs. Buffalo Trace | Bourbon Comparison

Two of the best names in widely available bourbon, Bulleit and Buffalo Trace are both great options. In this guide, we’ll break down the similarities and differences between these two high-quality products.

Bulleit vs. Buffalo Trace

Bulleit Bourbon:

  • History and Production: Bulleit has a history dating back to the 19th century. The modern Bulleit brand, known for its high-rye content, was revived by Tom Bulleit in 1987. It features a mash bill of 68% corn, 28% rye, and 4% malted barley.
  • Tasting Notes: Known for its bold and spicy flavor profile, it has notes of vanilla, rye spice, burnt sugar, tobacco, and cinnamon. The finish is smooth and creamy, which balances the spiciness.
  • Price: Average price for Bulleit Bourbon is around $29.
  • Is Bulleit Good for Old Fashioneds? Its bold and spicy character makes Bulleit a great choice for an Old Fashioned, providing a complex and balanced cocktail.

Buffalo Trace Bourbon:

  • History and Production: Buffalo Trace, one of America’s oldest distilleries, has a legacy closely intertwined with American bourbon history. The distillery has been operating for over two centuries. Their bourbon is known for its high corn content in the mash bill, although the exact proportions are not publicly disclosed.
  • Tasting Notes: Buffalo Trace Bourbon offers classic bourbon flavors with sweet notes of vanilla and caramel, alongside spicier tones of cinnamon, black pepper, and anise. It also has hints of oak and toffee, providing a well-rounded earthy finish.
  • Price: The average price for Buffalo Trace Bourbon is about $38 per bottle, making it an accessible choice for bourbon enthusiasts.
  • Is Buffalo Trace Good for Old Fashioneds? Buffalo Trace’s sweet and spicy profile makes it a versatile choice for cocktails, including the Old Fashioned. It can complement the cocktail’s ingredients well, offering a flavorful and smooth drinking experience.

Comparison and Conclusion

Here’s how the two bourbon options compare:

  • Flavor Profile: Bulleit is recognized for its higher rye content, offering a spicier and bolder flavor. In contrast, Buffalo Trace, with its high corn content, leans towards a sweeter and smoother profile.
  • Price Point: Both bourbons are similarly priced, offering good value in the mid-tier bourbon category.
  • Cocktail Suitability: Both Bulleit and Buffalo Trace are excellent choices for Old Fashioneds, with Bulleit offering a spicier take and Buffalo Trace providing a smoother and sweeter variation.

Each bourbon brings its unique characteristics to the table. Whether you prefer the spicier notes of Bulleit or the sweeter tones of Buffalo Trace, both are solid choices for bourbon lovers and mixologists alike​.

Get one (or both) of these bourbons delivered right to your door with Saucey. We offer same-day delivery in as little as 30 minutes. Just visit our website and enter your address to see what’s available in your area.

Leave a Comment

Start typing and press Enter to search