Captain Morgan vs. Sailor Jerry | Rum Comparison

Deciding between Captain Morgan and Sailor Jerry? Well, you’ve come to the perfect place to help make a decision. In this guide, we’ll break down the similarities and differences between these two popular rum brands.

Captain Morgan vs. Sailor Jerry

• History and Production: Created in 1944, Captain Morgan is named after the 17th-century Welsh privateer Sir Henry Morgan and has become one of the largest-selling rum brands in the US.
• Tasting Notes: Captain Morgan is famous for its rich natural vanilla and caramel flavors, enhanced by a complex blend of spices. It has a smooth, medium-bodied profile.
• Cocktail Suitability: This rum is a popular choice for a variety of cocktails, particularly those that benefit from its distinct spiced flavor, like Spiced Rum Mojitos or Captain and Cola.
• Average Price: Captain Morgan sits in the value tier of spiced rum; the current price for a 750ml bottle in your area is on Saucey, and it varies by state and retailer.

• History and Production: Sailor Jerry Rum was created to honor Norman ‘Sailor Jerry’ Collins, a prominent American tattoo artist. It is crafted in the U.S. Virgin Islands and then flavored and bottled in the U.S.
• Tasting Notes: Sailor Jerry features a bold vanilla and allspice scent, and a relatively dry, oaky flavor profile with a lively burst of allspice, cinnamon, and clove. It’s known for its strong character and excellent mixability.
• Cocktail Suitability: Its bold flavor profile makes it an excellent mixer for cocktails, adding depth and a distinctive spiced note to drinks.
• Average Price: Sailor Jerry is usually priced a step above Captain Morgan for the same 750ml bottle; check Saucey for the current price where you are.

Comparison and Conclusion

In a nutshell, here’s how the two rums compare:

• Flavor Profile: Captain Morgan offers a smoother, slightly sweeter spiced rum experience, whereas Sailor Jerry presents a bolder and more robust spice profile with a drier finish.
• Cocktail Preferences: Both rums are versatile for cocktails. Captain Morgan is ideal for those who prefer a sweeter, more subtly spiced cocktail, while Sailor Jerry is suited for cocktails that benefit from a stronger, spicier rum base.
• Price Point: The price points of both rums are similar, with Sailor Jerry being slightly higher. This may reflect its bold flavor profile and strong character.

Get either – or both – of these bottles delivered right to your door with Saucey. We deliver in as fast as 25 mins in the cities we serve. Just visit our website or app, enter your address, and browse rum options in your area.