Captain Morgan vs. Sailor Jerry | Rum Comparison

Deciding between Captain Morgan and Sailor Jerry? Well, you’ve come to the perfect place to help make a decision. In this guide, we’ll break down the similarities and differences between these two popular rum brands.

Captain Morgan vs. Sailor Jerry

  • History and Production: Created in 1944, Captain Morgan is named after the 17th-century Welsh privateer Sir Henry Morgan and has become one of the best-known rum brands.
  • Tasting Notes: Captain Morgan is famous for its rich natural vanilla and caramel flavors, enhanced by a complex blend of spices. It has a smooth, medium-bodied profile.
  • Cocktail Suitability: This rum is a popular choice for a variety of cocktails, particularly those that benefit from its distinct spiced flavor, like Spiced Rum Mojitos or Captain and Cola.
  • Average Price: Typically, Captain Morgan ranges from $15 to $25 for a 750ml bottle, depending on the region and retailer.

  • History and Production: Sailor Jerry Rum was created to honor Norman ‘Sailor Jerry’ Collins, a prominent American tattoo artist. It is crafted in the U.S. Virgin Islands and then flavored and bottled in the U.S.
  • Tasting Notes: Sailor Jerry features a bold vanilla and allspice scent, and a relatively dry, oaky flavor profile with a lively burst of allspice, cinnamon, and clove. It’s known for its strong character and excellent mixability.
  • Cocktail Suitability: Its bold flavor profile makes it an excellent mixer for cocktails, adding depth and a distinctive spiced note to drinks.
  • Average Price: The price for Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum is around $25 for a 750ml bottle.

Comparison and Conclusion

In a nutshell, here’s how the two rums compare:

  • Flavor Profile: Captain Morgan offers a smoother, slightly sweeter spiced rum experience, whereas Sailor Jerry presents a bolder and more robust spice profile with a drier finish.
  • Cocktail Preferences: Both rums are versatile for cocktails. Captain Morgan is ideal for those who prefer a sweeter, more subtly spiced cocktail, while Sailor Jerry is suited for cocktails that benefit from a stronger, spicier rum base.
  • Price Point: The price points of both rums are similar, with Sailor Jerry being slightly higher. This may reflect its bold flavor profile and strong character.

Get either – or both – of these bottles delivered right to your door with Saucey. We offer same-day alcohol delivery throughout the country. Just visit our website or app, enter your address, and browse rum options in your area.

Leave a Comment

Start typing and press Enter to search